Federal Constitutional Court Rejects FIA Employees' Plea for Pay Scale Upgradation
The Federal Constitutional Court has upheld an Islamabad High Court ruling, holding that pay scale upgradation is not an automatic or enforceable right for government employees, including those at the FIA.
Get this story and every big update first on WhatsAppFollow the around.pk English News channel — free, no spam Follow
The Federal Constitutional Court has dismissed petitions filed by employees of the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) who were seeking an upgrade to their pay scales, upholding an earlier verdict by the Islamabad High Court. The ruling closes a legal avenue that the employees had pursued in hopes of securing higher grades.
In its judgment, the court held that pay scale upgradation is neither automatic nor an enforceable right for government employees. It observed that courts cannot order such changes unless a specific government policy or legal provision provides a clear basis for doing so.
Justice Ali Baqar Najafi, who authored the five-page ruling, noted that decisions on policy matters rest within the authority of the executive branch. He stated that courts cannot interfere in administrative policies unless a matter involves a violation of fundamental rights or an unlawful or unconstitutional action.
The judgment also referred to the Federal Investigation Agency Act, 1974, under which the FIA operates. It observed that comparing the grades of employees working in different government departments is not legally justified, and that FIA staff cannot claim an upgrade solely because other departments offer better salaries or benefits.
The court concluded that courts cannot direct administrative authorities to upgrade employees' pay scales in the absence of a relevant policy or legal foundation. The decision reinforces the principle that pay and grade structures for public servants are matters for the executive to determine through established policy.
The ruling is expected to settle the question for FIA employees who had argued that their roles warranted higher grades. It also sets a precedent emphasising that judicial relief on service matters depends on an identifiable legal or policy basis rather than comparisons with other departments.
The story so far Federal Constitutional Court
- Federal Court Ruling on Infrastructure Cess Could Give 11 PSX Companies Rs. 43 Billion Tax Relief
- Top Court Rebukes LDA Over Frivolous Litigation Against Family of Nishan-e-Haider Recipient Rashid Minhas
- Supreme Court Clarifies Islamic Inheritance Shares, Upholds Cousin's Right to Residuary Estate







