Consumer Court Fines NDURE for Charging Customer for Branded Shopping Bag
A Peshawar consumer court has ruled that charging customers Rs. 20 for a branded shopping bag is an unfair trade practice, ordering NDURE to pay compensation and a fine.
Get this story and every big update first on WhatsAppFollow the around.pk English News channel — free, no spam Follow
A consumer court in Peshawar has ruled that charging customers for a branded shopping bag amounts to an unfair trade practice, in a decision that could influence how retailers across Pakistan handle packaging fees. Consumer Court Judge Nasrullah Gandapur issued the ruling against footwear brand NDURE after a customer challenged the Rs. 20 charge added to her bill.
According to the judgment, petitioner Sarah Sial bought a pair of shoes from NDURE's University Road outlet in Peshawar, where the company charged her Rs. 20 for a shopping bag. The court found that the bag, which carries the brand's logo, functions as an advertising and marketing tool for the company rather than a product the customer should pay for.
The court observed that Sial had visited the store to buy shoes, not the brand's promotional material, and that customers do not act as the company's marketing agents. On that basis, it concluded that requiring shoppers to pay for bags that promote the brand's identity is an unfair trade practice under consumer protection rules.
The ruling requires NDURE to pay Rs. 20,000 in compensation to the customer and to deposit a further Rs. 20,000 as a fine into the government treasury. The company has also been directed to refund the Rs. 20 it charged for the shopping bag.
The decision highlights growing scrutiny of add-on charges at retail outlets, where customers are increasingly billed separately for bags and packaging. Consumer rights advocates say such fees can be difficult for shoppers to challenge at the point of sale, making court rulings an important check on retail practices.
The case is notable for setting a precedent that other retailers may need to consider when deciding whether to pass packaging costs on to customers. For consumers, it reinforces the principle that promotional items tied to a brand's image should not be billed as an extra charge at checkout.
The story so far University Road
- Sindh Government to Launch Operation Against Encroachments on Karachi's Major Roads
- TransKarachi Sets 30 km/h Speed Limit for New Elevated U-Turn on University Road
- TransKarachi Explains Space Constraints Behind Narrow University Road U-Turn
- Karachi's New Single-Lane Elevated U-Turn on University Road Faces Public Criticism











